By Fred Schulte
Lenia Watson-Burton, a 37-year-old U.S. Navy administrator, anticipated that beauty surgical procedure would do away with cussed fats shortly and simply — simply because the online advertising promised.
As a substitute, she died three days after a liposuction-like process referred to as AirSculpt on the San Diego workplace of Elite Physique Sculpture, a beauty surgical procedure chain with greater than 30 workplaces throughout the U.S. and Canada, courtroom data present.
Beauty surgical procedure chains organising store in a number of states rely closely on promoting to draw prospects: tv, print, social media influencers, even texts hawking discounted vacation charges. The pitches sometimes promise sufferers life-changing physique shaping with minimal ache and a fast restoration.
RELATED: The Unseen Prices of Our Magnificence Obsession
But there’s no federal requirement that surgical procedure firms put up proof supporting the reality and accuracy of those advertising claims. No company tracks how continuously sufferers persuaded by gross sales pitches maintain painful issues comparable to infections, how successfully surgeons and nursing workers comply with up and deal with accidents, or whether or not firms promoting new aesthetic gadgets and strategies have adequately educated surgeons to make use of them safely.
In 2023, Watson-Burton’s husband and 6 youngsters and stepchildren sued Elite Physique Sculpture and plastic surgeon Heidi Regenass for medical malpractice, alleging that the skinny cannula the surgeon used to take away fats perforated Watson-Burton’s bowel, inflicting her loss of life.
The go well with additionally accused Elite Physique Sculpture of posting false or deceptive promoting on its web site, comparable to describing the clinic’s branded process AirSculpt as “mild on the physique” and stating: “Our sufferers take the fewest attainable dangers and get again to their common routine as quickly as 24-48 hours post-operation.”
Watson-Burton was considered one of three sufferers who died after having liposuction and fats switch operations carried out by Regenass from October 2022 to February 2023, courtroom data state. Households of all three ladies sued the surgeon, who denied wrongdoing in authorized filings. The events settled the Watson-Burton household case in 2024. Two different wrongful loss of life circumstances are pending, together with a go well with by an Ohio girl who alleges her mom relied on guarantees on Regenass’ web site that the operation in California can be protected with a fast restoration.
Neither Regenass nor her attorneys responded to repeated requests for remark. Emails and telephone calls to Elite Physique Sculpture’s Miami headquarters weren’t returned.
State and federal authorities do have the ability to ban false or deceptive medical promoting of every type, although enforcement is spotty, significantly when promotions pop up on-line. Meaning sufferers should do their very own homework in evaluating beauty surgical procedure advertising pitches.
“Whereas shoppers ought to be capable of belief that advert claims are substantiated as a result of the regulation requires them to be, the fact is that it pays for shoppers to deliver a skeptical eye,” stated Mary Engle, an govt vp at BBB Nationwide Packages.
‘Up a Cup’
Based by beauty surgeon Aaron Rollins, Elite Physique Sculpture says in Securities and Trade Fee filings that it gives a “premium affected person expertise and splendid, spa-like ambiance” at its rising community of facilities. The publicly traded firm, based mostly in Miami Seaside and backed by personal fairness traders, markets AirSculpt as being “a lot much less invasive than conventional liposuction” and offering “sooner therapeutic with superior outcomes.” The advertisements say that AirSculpt “requires no scalpel, or stitches, and solely leaves behind a freckle-sized scar!” and that sufferers “stay awake the entire time and might stroll proper out of their process, having fun with dramatic outcomes!” Some dangers are disclosed.
Rollins, who just lately made headlines for placing his Indian Creek mansion available on the market for $200 million, didn’t reply to repeated requests for remark. A lawyer for Rollins, Robert Peal, responded to an e mail however didn’t remark. On Nov. 4, the firm introduced that Rollins had resigned as govt chairman of the board of administrators of AirSculpt Applied sciences and as a member of the board.
Many AirSculpt sufferers choose to have fats that’s faraway from their stomachs or different locations injected into their buttocks, usually referred to as a Brazilian butt raise. Others use the fats to boost their breasts, a process the corporate manufacturers as “Up a Cup.” Since March 2023, at the least seven sufferers have filed lawsuits accusing Elite Physique Sculpture of operating deceptive promoting or misrepresenting outcomes, arguing, amongst different issues, that they felt extra ache or healed way more slowly than the advertisements led them to imagine they’d, courtroom data present. One of many lawsuits has been dismissed, and the corporate has denied the allegations in others.
The Watson-Burton household argued of their lawsuit that some advertising claims about AirSculpt had been merely not true.
For example, Elite Physique Sculpture’s web site acknowledged that AirSculpt has “automated know-how” set to “flip off” earlier than the cannula penetrates the physique too deeply and presumably causes severe damage, in accordance with the go well with. That function didn’t defend Watson-Burton, who paid $12,000 for the operation, hoping for a “fast and well timed restoration” earlier than a scheduled U.S. Navy deployment, in accordance with the lawsuit.
Somewhat than being mild on the physique, AirSculpt was “extraordinarily painful, extremely invasive, unsafe, required greater than a brief 24-hour restoration interval and will and did harm inner organs,” in accordance with the go well with.
Watson-Burton referred to as the San Diego heart on Oct. 27, 2022, a day after the operation, to report “extreme ache” in her higher stomach, however staffers took no motion to guage her, in accordance with the go well with. The following morning, an ambulance rushed her to a hospital, the place emergency surgical procedure confirmed the gravity of her accidents. Surgeons famous her accidents included three perforations of the small bowel and sepsis.
Watson-Burton died on Oct. 29, 2022. An post-mortem report cited issues of the beauty surgical procedure, ruling she died after changing into “septic following intraoperative small bowel perforation.” Her loss of life certificates lists the trigger as “issues of abdominoplasty.”
In courtroom filings, Elite Physique Sculpture stated Watson-Burton had “skilled an unusual surgical complication.” The corporate denied that it made any “particular assure or illustration that damage to organs couldn’t happen.” It denied any legal responsibility or that its advertisements made misrepresentations.
The dispute by no means performed out absolutely in courtroom. The events settled the case in August 2024, when Elite Physique Sculpture agreed to pay Watson-Burton’s household $2 million, the utmost below its insurance coverage coverage. Regenass, the surgeon, who didn’t carry legal responsibility insurance coverage, agreed to pay $100,000 extra, in accordance with the settlement settlement.
Guarantees Not Stored
Social media pitches and online advertising additionally led Tamala Smith, 55, of Toledo, Ohio, to Regenass for liposuction and a fats switch, courtroom data state.
Smith was lifeless lower than two weeks later, considered one of two different ladies who died following elective operations Regenass carried out from December 2022 to February 2023, courtroom data present. The surgeon operated on the 2 ladies at Pacific Liposculpture, which runs three surgical procedure facilities in Southern California, courtroom data state.
The households of each ladies are suing Regenass, a board-certified plastic surgeon, and the surgical procedure heart. In each circumstances, that are pending in California courts, Regenass and the surgical procedure heart have denied the allegations and filed dismissal motions that deny accountability for the deaths.
Smith was a touring registered nurse working the in a single day shift at a hospital in Los Angeles. She selected Regenass after viewing the physician’s Instagram web page, in accordance with a lawsuit filed by Smith’s daughter, Ste’Aira Ballard, who lives in Toledo.
The advertisements described the surgeon as an “awake liposuction and fats switch specialist,” whereas her web site assured sufferers they’d really feel minimal ache and be “again to work in 24-48 hours,” in accordance with the go well with.
Through the three-hour operation on Feb. 8, 2023, at Pacific Liposculpture’s Newport Seaside workplace, Regenass eliminated fats from Smith’s stomach and flanks and redistributed it to her buttocks, in accordance with the go well with. Smith referred to as the workplace at the least twice in subsequent days to report ache and swelling, however a staffer advised her that was regular, in accordance with the go well with. Smith by no means spoke to the surgeon, in accordance with the go well with.
When Ballard couldn’t attain her mom, she referred to as the hospital solely to be taught Smith hadn’t turned up for her in a single day shift for 2 days. The hospital referred to as police and requested for a welfare test on the extended-stay resort in Glendale, California, the place Smith had been dwelling.
An officer found her physique on the mattress “surrounded by towels and sheets which are stained with brown and inexperienced fluids,” in accordance with a coroner’s report within the courtroom file. A countertop within the room was “lined in medical paperwork detailing post-operative directions from a liposuction clinic,” in accordance with the report. Ballard stated she realized of her mom’s loss of life when she referred to as Smith’s cellphone; a police officer answered and delivered the devastating information.
“Oh, my God, I fell to the ground,” Ballard stated in an interview with KFF Well being Information and NBC Information. Ballard stated she nonetheless has not gotten over the shock and grief. “It bothers me as a result of how does somebody that devoted their life to avoid wasting different individuals’s lives find yourself deceased in a resort, as if her life didn’t matter?” she requested.
Ballard stated her mom trusted Regenass based mostly on her internet persona. She believes her mom, a registered nurse, wouldn’t have gone to the surgeon had she recognized somebody had died after an operation Regenass carried out on the Pacific Liposculpture San Diego workplace. Terri Bishop, 55, a truck driving teacher who lived in Temecula, California, died on Dec. 24, 2022, about three weeks after present process liposuction and fats switch at Pacific Liposculpture, an organization with a historical past of run-ins with state regulators.
Pacific Liposculpture didn’t reply to requests for remark. In courtroom filings, the corporate has denied that the operations performed a task in both affected person’s loss of life and moved to dismiss the circumstances. The corporate additionally argued that Ballard waited too lengthy to file go well with.
Bishop, who had a historical past of smoking, diabetes, and hypertension, died from “arteriosclerotic heart problems aggravated by viral pneumonia (Influenza A H1 2009),” in accordance with a Riverside County health worker’s report made a part of the courtroom file. The household disagrees and is arguing that Bishop died from blood clots, a recognized complication of surgical procedure. A trial is about for June 2026.
In Smith’s case, the Los Angeles County health worker dominated the nurse died of “renal failure of unknown trigger.” The post-mortem report famous: “This can be a pure loss of life since an damage straight from the surgical procedure can’t be recognized.”
Ballard is demanding additional investigation to unravel what occurred to her mom.
“I don’t assume they had been easy with the danger and issues that would happen,” Ballard stated. “I feel they’re promising individuals stuff they’ll’t ship.”
Ballard filed a grievance towards Regenass with the California Medical Board, which the board is investigating, in accordance with paperwork she offered to KFF Well being Information and NBC Information. She believes regulators have to be extra clear in regards to the backgrounds of surgeons who provide providers to the general public. She additionally hopes the investigation will shake unfastened extra particulars of what occurred to her mom.
“I simply don’t perceive how she got here again to me in a physique bag,” she stated.
‘Purchaser Beware’
Considerations about gross sales pitches for beauty surgical procedure date again a long time.
Witnesses testifying at a June 1989 congressional listening to held by a subcommittee of the Home Small Enterprise Committee in Washington heard a litany of horror tales of sufferers maimed by surgeons with doubtful coaching and credentials. Subcommittee Chairman Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) stated sufferers had been victimized by misleading and false advertisements that promised a “fast, straightforward and painless solution to change your life — all by means of the beauty surgical procedure miracle.”
Calling for reform, Wyden added: “So, beauty surgical procedure shoppers are largely on their very own. It’s again to a purchaser beware market, and it smacks extra of used automotive gross sales than medication.” Wyden now represents Oregon within the U.S. Senate.
All these years later, there’s much more territory to police: an onslaught of online advertising, comparable to splashy “earlier than and after” pictures, on-line posts, and podcasts by social media influencers and others courted by surgical procedure firms in a pricey effort to draw enterprise. Elite Physique Sculpture, as an illustration, spent $43.9 million in “promoting bills” in 2024. That got here to $3,130 per “buyer acquisition,” in accordance with the corporate’s SEC filings.
Underneath Federal Commerce Fee pointers, medical promoting have to be “truthful, not misleading, and backed up by competent and dependable scientific proof,” in accordance with Janice Kopec of the company’s Bureau of Shopper Safety.
Any claims which are “steered or fairly implied” by advertisements additionally have to be correct. That features the “internet impression” conveyed by textual content and any charts, graphs, and different pictures, in accordance with the FTC. The company declined to elaborate.
Medical companies are free to determine what documentation, if any, to share with the general public. Most beauty surgical procedure websites provide little or no such assist for particular claims — comparable to restoration occasions or ache ranges — on their web sites.
“There is no such thing as a requirement that the substantiation be made accessible to shoppers, both on a web site or upon demand,” Engle, who can also be a former FTC official, stated in an e mail.
The regulation permits “puffery,” or boastful statements that no particular person would doubtless take at face worth, or that may’t be proved, comparable to, “‘You’ve tried all the remaining, now attempt the very best,’” Engle stated.
The place to attract the road between acceptable boasts and unverified claims might be contentious.
Athēnix, a personal equity-backed beauty surgical procedure chain with places in six cities, defended its use of phrases comparable to “safer” and “higher outcomes” as puffery in response to a false promoting lawsuit filed towards the corporate by Orange County District Legal professional Todd Spitzer in California in August 2022.
Spitzer argued that Athēnix touted its “micro-body-contouring” method as “safer” than conventional liposuction and supplied “excellent outcomes with much less ache and downtime” with out backing that up, in accordance with the go well with.
“There is no such thing as a examine or proof to assist these statements and no scientific consensus about the usage of these new methods,” Spitzer argued.
The events settled the case in July 2023 when Athēnix agreed to pay $25,000 with out admitting wrongdoing, courtroom data present. Earlier than the settlement, Athēnix argued that its use of phrases comparable to “safer” and “higher outcomes” was “subjective” and “puffery” — and never false promoting.
Whereas there’s little indication that native or state authorities are stepping up scrutiny of beauty surgical procedure promoting, federal authorities have signaled they intend to crack down on doubtful promoting claims made by drug producers.
In a letter despatched to drug firms in September, FDA Commissioner Marty Makary wrote that “misleading promoting is unfortunately the present norm” on social media platforms and that the company would now not tolerate these violations.
‘Dangerous Recommendation’
To show medical negligence, injured sufferers typically should present that their care fell beneath what a “fairly prudent” physician with related coaching would have offered. Of their protection, surgeons might argue that issues are a threat of any operation and {that a} poor consequence doesn’t imply the physician was negligent.
Some lawsuits filed by injured sufferers add allegations that ads by surgical procedure chains misled them, or that surgeons failed to totally clarify attainable dangers of accidents, a requirement recognized in medical circles as knowledgeable consent.
Caitlin Meehan had such a case. She underwent a $15,000 AirSculpt process at Elite Physique Sculpture’s clinic in Wayne, Pennsylvania, exterior Philadelphia. She agreed to the surgical procedure in March 2023, she stated, as a result of the corporate’s web site described it as “Lunch Time Lipo,” in accordance with a lawsuit she filed in late August. The go well with alleges that the physician she mentioned the process with “maintained that there are not any severe, life-threatening, lasting and/or everlasting issues,” in accordance with the go well with.
Through the process, nonetheless, gases grew to become trapped beneath her pores and skin, inflicting a widespread swelling referred to as subcutaneous emphysema, in accordance with the go well with. Meehan was shocked to see her face, neck, and higher physique severely swollen, inflicting her shortness of breath.
A pal who drove her to the appointment requested the workers to name an ambulance, however workers members stated that wasn’t needed, in accordance with the go well with. After an hour’s drive house, Meehan stated her pores and skin felt prefer it was burning and she or he referred to as 911. She spent 4 days within the hospital recovering and stays scarred, in accordance with the go well with. The go well with is pending, and the corporate has but to file a solution in courtroom.
Scott Hollenbeck, speedy previous president of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, stated recovering from liposuction in a day “appears unrealistic” given the bruising and swelling that may happen.
“The concept you possibly can return to work 24 hours after efficient liposuction looks as if extraordinarily unhealthy recommendation,” Hollenbeck stated.
‘I Felt Horrible’
Advertisements that promised sufferers minimal discomfort even have come below assault in affected person lawsuits.
Greater than 20 different medical malpractice circumstances reviewed by KFF Well being Information made related allegations of sudden ache throughout operations at beauty surgical procedure chains utilizing lidocaine for ache reduction in “awake liposuction.”
One affected person suing Elite Physique Sculpture in Cook dinner County, Illinois, alleged she “was crying attributable to [the] extreme ache” of an operation in September 2023. She alleged the physician stated he couldn’t give her any extra native anesthetic and pressed on with the process. The defendants haven’t filed a solution in courtroom. The observe didn’t reply to a request for remark.
Engle, the previous FTC official, stated that whereas claims of discomfort are considerably subjective, they nonetheless have to be “truthful and substantiated,” comparable to supported by a “legitimate, dependable scientific examine of sufferers’ expertise.”
NBC Information producer Jason Kane contributed to this report.
