What Is The Difference Between Pumpkin Pie And Sweet Potato Pie?

Pumpkin pie vs. candy potato pie – What’s the distinction between pumpkin and candy potato pies?

It might seem to be candy potato pie is only a fancier, extra flavorful model of pumpkin pie (and it’s). And each pie fillings look related in shade, and the crust seems the identical. Nonetheless, there are some vital variations between the 2. 

Many of the variations contain the place one was raised, their ethnicity, or race. These elements are vital to how pumpkin and candy potato pies are ready.

Study extra in my publish about why Black individuals eat candy potato pie as a substitute of pumpkin.

Are pumpkin and candy potato interchangeable?

Whereas each pies are Southern desserts and vegetarian-friendly. It’d be blasphemy within the Black Southern cooks’ neighborhood to even recommend that it’s OK to interchange the 2!

Pumpkin pies are historically made with sugar and some spices. Candy potato pies have been elevated with soulful taste mixtures like cinnamon, sugar, candy vanilla, cloves, and nutmeg. Blended superbly with softened candy potatoes.

What pie do Black individuals eat on Thanksgiving?

For Thanksgiving dinner, pumpkin pies are historically discovered on the kitchen tables in lots of houses of White People. Whereas candy potato pie is the go-to custom for a Black household Thanksgiving.

Study extra in my posts about candy potato pie Black historical past and why is nice potato pie a Black factor.

Do pumpkin pie and candy potato pie style related?

Pumpkin pie and candy potato pie don’t style the identical.

Most pumpkin pies are usually bland, dense, and creamier. Even with the addition of pumpkin pie spice, pumpkin pie is not any comparability to a Black of us’ candy potato pie recipe. 

In distinction, candy potato pie has extra texture and an airier and fluffier filling with a handful of one of the best soul meals candy potato pie spices and candy potato pie substances to attain a silky easy texture and flavorful style.

Is pumpkin pie filling constructed from candy potatoes?

The pie fillings of candy potato and pumpkin pies differ as a result of pumpkins are gourd greens like squash, and candy potatoes are root greens, just like yams (though candy potatoes usually are not the identical as yams). Thus, the style and texture of the fillings usually are not the identical.

Which is best, candy potato or pumpkin?

If you happen to ask Black of us, there is no such thing as a debate about which one is best. The reply is at all times candy potato pie – so long as it’s made the Black of us’ soul meals manner!

Nevertheless, when you examine the 2 side-by-side, candy potato typically outpaces pumpkin in its dietary make-up from vitamin A to fiber to protein. In keeping with Yahoo’s fall diet face-off: “Whereas pumpkin is a light-weight, low-sugar choice, candy potatoes do extra heavy lifting and can finally feed your physique extra important vitamins.”

Candy potato pie vs. pumpkin pie meme

The talk between loyalists of candy potato pie and pumpkin pie will possible proceed, sparking social dialogue from Reddit solutions to Fb posts, Instagram Tales, and TikTok video explanations. It additionally lives on by means of photos and memes!

However in conclusion, which is best? Pumpkin or candy potato pie? It usually boils down to not the pumpkin or candy potato purée. However as a substitute, your private style.

Which one is your favourite between pumpkin pie and candy potato pie?

If you happen to have been taking part in a recreation, which one has received to go?

Remark under and lemme know. 

Then subscribe HERE for all of the soul meals!

That is one of the best candy potato pie recipe with one of the best taste! 

Like this publish? Pin the under picture to your Pinterest “Soul Meals Recipes” board!