Who can neglect the wild rumors surrounding Jennifer Lopez and Alex Rodriguez’s damaged engagement after whispers of infidelity took over actuality tv?
The subject got here up throughout Lopez’s current look on Andy Cohen’s “What What Occurs Stay.” Whereas taking part in a recreation of “Plead the Fifth,” the place Cohen asks his visitors juicy questions and they’re solely allowed to go on one, Lopez was requested about her breakup with Rodriguez, and, surprisingly, the mom of two selected to reply.
‘You Can’t Hold It In Your Pants’: Jennifer Lopez’s Ex-Husband Drops Bombshell Allegations About Affairs and Management Behind the Scenes
“It got here up at a ‘Southern Allure’ reunion a number of years in the past: That your ex A-Rod was DMing one of many forged members. And there was loads of hypothesis within the press or on the present that someway led to your breakup. Is there something you possibly can converse to about that?” Cohen mentioned to Lopez.
👀 Jennifer Lopez was put within the scorching seat when she appeared on the Wednesday, October 15, episode of Watch What Occurs Stay.
Throughout the installment, host Andy Cohen confronted the celebrity over previous rumors that her ex-fiancé Alex Rodriguez was flirting with Madison LeCroy whereas… pic.twitter.com/r4sA75fWXr
— OK! Journal USA (@OKMagazine) October 16, 2025
“Southern Allure” is a actuality TV present that navigates the love lives and drama surrounding a bunch of rich socialites in Charleston, South Carolina. Madison LeCroy is without doubt one of the stars of the present — and was rumored to be the reason for Lopez and Rodriguez’s breakup.
After letting out a deep sigh, Lopez took a pause and seemed off as if she have been trying to find a response.
When it lastly got here to her, she answered however selected to go the secure route. “, I actually don’t have anything to say about my private life anymore. I really feel like … I’m performed with that.”
Earlier than she might transfer on, the singer obtained an ovation from Cohen’s dwell viewers, and in return she smiled and yelled again, “Sure! Assist!”
Readers responded beneath the New York Submit’s story in regards to the interview with little to no regret for the “If You Had My Love” singer.
One particular person mentioned, “Who can blame Alex? One other wrote, “I imply, come on. Simply take a look at her. She’s 10x hotter than JLo might ever be.”
A 3rd added, “Nothing flawed with elevating your recreation however not whenever you’re married.”
The “Kiss of the Spider Girl” star and the previous New York Yankees participant started relationship in 2017. They acquired engaged two years later however known as it off in 2021 after suspending the marriage twice.
In April 2021, Lopez and Rodriguez launched a joint assertion, confirming, “We have now realized we’re higher as pals and sit up for remaining so.”
However hypothesis that the true reason behind the demise of their union was LeCroy had already begun brewing throughout season 7 of the Bravo collection. The rumor that LeCroy was having an affair with a married former MLB participant began on the present’s reunion in January 2021.
LeCroy’s forged mate Craig Conover accused her of stepping out on her then-boyfriend, Austen Kroll, whereas they have been making an attempt to work issues out.
He mentioned, “You have been flying across the nation sleeping with married males – ex-MLB gamers! That’s what you have been doing throughout quarantine.”
Cohen, who hosted the reunion on the time, requested LeCroy to make clear if she had been instantly messaging the unidentified former athlete.
She mentioned, “He contacted me and, sure, we DM’d, however apart from that, there was nothing. I’ve by no means bodily seen him, touched him.”
After the reunion, on-line customers investigated to seek out out what former baseball participant LeCroy was talking about. Followers finally found that Rodriguez had appreciated a number of of her photographs on Instagram. He later eliminated his likes, however not earlier than followers took screenshots.
Rumors about Lopez and Rodriguez’s cut up adopted as early as March, earlier than they launched an official assertion the subsequent month.
In 2023, LeCroy went on Kroll’s podcast “Pillows and Beers” and admitted that Rodriguez was the one DMing her.
Kroll jumped in, including, “He saved on FaceTiming you advert nauseam.” She claimed that Rodriguez would FaceTime her three to 4 occasions every day and allegedly acquired upset with LeCroy one time when she didn’t reply.
LeCroy added, “I advised [Alex], I mentioned, ‘In case you’re in search of a facet chick, which clearly he was, it wasn’t gonna be me. I’m wifey materials.”
She maintains that she and Rodriguez by no means met in particular person, and Rodriguez’s rep denied the rumors.
