The co-director of a racial justice group criticized as “grossly insufficient” an essay by former President Barack Obama that supported Israel’s proper to defend itself whereas warning towards reducing off fundamental must the Gaza Strip.
Rachel Gilmer, co-director of the Dream Defenders, advised theGrio that the previous president’s essay in Medium “is simply persevering with to type of normalize and chalk up the intense violence and genocide that the Israeli authorities is committing towards the Palestinian individuals.”
In his essay titled “Ideas on Israel and Gaza,” Obama wrote, “It’s been 17 days since Hamas launched its horrific assault towards Israel, killing over 1,400 Israeli residents, together with defenseless ladies, kids and the aged.”
He added, “Within the aftermath of such unspeakable brutality, the U.S. authorities and the American individuals have shared within the grief of households, prayed for the return of family members, and rightly declared solidarity with the Israeli individuals.”
However, Obama additionally cautioned Israel towards exacerbating a “rising humanitarian disaster.”
He wrote, “The Israeli authorities’s resolution to chop off meals, water and electrical energy to a captive civilian inhabitants (in Gaza) threatens not solely to worsen a rising humanitarian disaster; it may additional harden Palestinian attitudes for generations, erode international assist for Israel, play into the arms of Israel’s enemies, and undermine long-term efforts to attain peace and stability within the area.”
Referencing the humanitarian points, Gilmer mentioned, “5 thousand plus individuals have been killed in Gaza, hundreds of kids, Gaza’s whole hospital system has completely collapsed, individuals have misplaced whole households.”
“This was an actual missed alternative for Obama to face on the correct aspect of historical past to carry the Israeli authorities accountable for its battle crimes. For its ethnic cleaning of the Palestinian individuals,” she continued.
Obama’s assertion comes greater than two weeks after the Oct. 7 begin of the Israel-Hamas battle, which has resulted within the deaths of hundreds of harmless civilians in each Israel and the Gaza Strip.
Israeli authorities say greater than 1,400 individuals died when Hamas launched its assault and greater than 200 individuals had been taken hostage. 4 hostages have since been launched. Well being authorities in Gazas say greater than 5,000 individuals have died and greater than 15,000 have been injured, in response to CNBC.
Paul O’Brien, govt director of Amnesty Worldwide, advised theGrio that Obama’s assertion was issued “too late.”
“President Obama ought to have spoken earlier, and in supporting President Biden, he ought to have made it clear that President Biden must be doing extra,” he mentioned.
“I imagine that the US has a singular affect with Israel and it ought to have carried out every thing in its energy from the very outset to make sure that Israel adhered to worldwide humanitarian legislation,” he mentioned.
Final week, President Joe Biden delivered a speech concerning the Israel-Hamas battle and spotlighted the hundreds of harmless lives misplaced in each Israel and Gaza.
O’Brien mentioned Biden’s remarks additionally got here too late.
“Whereas it’s good President Biden has not too long ago began to acknowledge that the safety of civilians by the Israeli navy is an curiosity of the US, he didn’t say it strongly sufficient and early sufficient,” he mentioned.
O’Brien added, “Within the president’s speech he may have each held Hamas to account for his or her egregious acts and mentioned that the Palestinians aren’t accountable and shouldn’t be topic to collective punishment.”
Some criticized Biden for not mentioning a ceasefire throughout his remarks.
“Proper now, there are millions of Individuals marching by the streets calling for a ceasefire…that’s throughout political events, race, all people is looking for a ceasefire,” Gilmer mentioned.
“For Obama to do something lower than name for a ceasefire proper now’s solely contributing to the genocide that we’re seeing happen in Gaza,” she added.
Final week, 13 progressive Home Democrats launched a decision calling for Biden to demand a ceasefire to stop additional bloodshed.
However O’Brien mentioned he agreed with Obama’s essay and that “The collective punishment of harmless individuals in any context shouldn’t be going to be good for our world.”
He added, “It’s not going to be good for Israel in the long run and it’s definitely not going to be good for the Palestinian inhabitants who aren’t liable for what Hamas did on Oct. 7.”
“Worse issues are more likely to occur if the US doesn’t demand restraint by Israel.”
TheGrio is FREE in your TV by way of Apple TV, Amazon Hearth, Roku, and Android TV. Please obtain theGrio cell apps as we speak!
