If candy potato pie is the crown jewel of the desk, the crust is the throne it sits on! And in a Black of us’ kitchen, we don’t deal with pie crust like an afterthought. We deal with it like infrastructure.
The bottom needs to be sturdy sufficient to carry a silky custard, flaky sufficient to chop clear, and golden sufficient to border each slice prefer it belongs there. As a result of when that knife goes in?The crust ought to whisper — not crack.
This information walks you thru precisely how to decide on, make, and bake one of the best crust for candy potato pie, the Southern soul meals approach.
The Soul Meals Pot® preserves African American baking traditions with expert-tested methods that defend texture, taste, and legacy — from the crust up!
Why Black of us prepare dinner it this fashion
Black cooks mastered candy potato pie by balancing restraint with richness. And that steadiness begins with the crust. Our pies are custard-based. Silky. Deeply spiced. Gently candy. So the crust can’t compete… and it may well’t overpower. It should assist the filling with out over-browning, over-baking, or turning robust.
That’s why in my household’s trusted and examined Black Of us Candy Potato Pie Recipe™, we do not blind-bake the crust. Blind baking dangers an overcooked or burnt edge earlier than the custard has time to set correctly. We bake it collectively — filling and crust in concord — low and regular. As a result of good pie is about rhythm!
What’s the finest crust for candy potato pie?
The very best crust for candy potato pie is a conventional Southern shortcrust pastry. What you’ll usually see labeled in US grocery shops as “pie crust pastry,” whether or not brand-name or store-bought roll-out dough, or pie shell in a disposable pan. It’s flaky, however not crumbly. Tender, however not gentle. And structured, however by no means thick or doughy.
Candy potato pie is a custard-based pie. It’s heavier and silkier than fruit pie, which implies the crust has actual work to do. It should assist the filling with out getting soggy, collapsing, or overpowering the feel of the custard.
Butter vs. shortening — which is best?
Both a traditional butter or a butter-shortening mix works finest for a home made candy potato pie crust. Butter delivers taste and golden coloration, whereas shortening provides stability and flake, making a crust that bakes evenly alongside the filling and slices clear from edge to heart.
My suggestion? I exploit a mix. Butter for style. Shortening for stability. That mixture creates a crust that slices clear and holds its form beneath custard.
What to anticipate when making this crust
Chill and prep the butter — Freeze and grate the butter into small bits, then combine it with the shortening and dry substances till crumbly.
Add water and kind the dough — Drizzle within the water till the dough holds collectively, then press the dough right into a ball.
Relaxation and refrigerate – Wrap and refrigerate the dough for no less than 6 hours to loosen up the gluten and agency the butter for a young, flaky crust.
Roll, match, and crimp — Roll the dough, match it into the pie plate, and crimp or flute the perimeters.
Do you have to blind bake candy potato pie crust?
Quick reply? Not for this pie. Blind baking is once you bake the pie crust earlier than including the filling. Candy potato pie is a custard pie. It bakes low and sluggish. The filling wants time to set gently. If you happen to blind bake first, the crust edges can overcook earlier than the middle is finished.
As a substitute, use an unbaked crust, bake on the decrease oven rack, and protect edges midway by means of if wanted. (Pie shields have entered the chat!) That’s the way you defend the crust whereas the custard units.
How you can bake a candy potato pie crust the fitting approach
Right here’s what works, after testing numerous instances in my very own kitchen:
Begin with a calming crust (Let the ready crust chill for six hours, or ideally in a single day)
Fill instantly after rolling and inserting within the pie pan
Bake at a average temperature (by no means too excessive)
Place pie on the decrease rack for backside browning
Add a pie protect if edges brown too quick
You’ll know the crust is finished when:
The perimeters are golden
The underside feels agency
The filling is puffed and set
That’s concord.
How you can hold your crust from getting soggy
Custard pies can intimidate bakers. However right here’s how we forestall soggy bottoms:
Use contemporary candy potatoes (not watery canned ones)
Don’t overmix the filling
Bake lengthy sufficient for full custard set
Let the pie cool fully earlier than slicing
🥄 Shaunda says: Cooling shouldn’t be non-compulsory. Custard pies end setting as they relaxation, so letting your candy potato pie cool fully is crucial for clear slices, correct construction, and full taste growth.
Deep-dish vs. common crust — which is best?
Deep-dish offers you extra filling and a thicker edge. But it surely additionally requires:
For rookies? Normal depth is perhaps simpler to manage.
For Thanksgiving veterans? A 9-inch deep dish, my private favourite, makes an announcement!
Retailer-bought vs. home made crust
What you actually need to know is — can you employ a store-bought crust?
Let’s be sincere. There’s no disgrace in store-bought pie crust pastry, particularly throughout busy vacation prep. Probably the most decorated-in-the-kitchen Grandmas and Aunties (together with me!) have been pulling these ready-made pie crusts in disposable steel pans out of grocery luggage for so long as I can keep in mind… and nobody has ever skipped a slice!
Now, right here’s the reality. If you need full management over texture and taste? Do-it-yourself wins.
As a result of once you management the fats ratio, the coolness time, and the thickness of the dough, you management the chunk. You management the flake. You management how that crust bakes round your custard filling. And that degree of management is what turns a very good pie right into a signature one.
Widespread pie crust errors (and the best way to keep away from them)
As a result of small changes make huge variations.
Shrinking crust? Chill it longer earlier than baking.
Powerful texture? You dealt with the dough an excessive amount of.
Burnt edges? Use a protect earlier.
Pale backside? Bake on a decrease rack.
✨ Shaunda’s Soul Meals Sense: ideas, truths & traditions
Preserve substances chilly, particularly the butter, to realize a flaky pie crust
Use small items of butter for simpler mixing and tender layers
Roll dough evenly with no thick edges
Don’t stretch dough into the pan
Crimp gently, not tightly (Professional tip: As a substitute, use a fluted pan that ruffles for you!)
All the time let the completed pie cool no less than 4 hours — That remaining relaxation is what offers you these clear, assured slices!
Candy potato pie isn’t rushed. And neither is the crust. It’s constructed to carry legacy. To hold spice. To border a slice that tastes like dwelling. When accomplished proper, the crust doesn’t steal the highlight. It earns its place round it.
And in case you actually need to bake it proper the primary time, don’t miss my information on errors to keep away from when making candy potato pie, as a result of defending the crust is simply half the story!
Make-ahead and freezing ideas
Make-ahead dough — Form the pastry right into a disc, wrap tightly in plastic wrap, and refrigerate for as much as 3 days. The remainder time truly improves the feel by permitting the gluten to loosen up and the butter to agency again up.
Make-ahead pie shell — Roll out the dough, match it into your pie pan, crimp the perimeters, and canopy loosely. Refrigerate for as much as 3 days. When prepared, fill and bake straight from the fridge. This works superbly for candy potato pie!
Freezing dough — Wrap the dough disc tightly in plastic wrap, then place in a freezer bag or hermetic container. Freeze for as much as 3 months. Thaw in a single day within the fridge earlier than rolling.
Freezing pie shells — Unbaked, formed pie shells might be wrapped tightly and frozen for as much as 3 months. Thaw at room temperature for 10-20 minutes, then merely fill and bake!
Carrying the legacy ahead
An excellent candy potato pie begins earlier than the filling ever touches the pan. Once you hold your butter chilly, let the dough relaxation, roll with intention, defend the perimeters, and bake crust and custard collectively the fitting approach, you’re respecting the construction that holds the story.
As a result of in soul meals baking, the crust isn’t an afterthought. It’s the muse. Golden, buttery, flaky, and powerful sufficient to hold one thing significant.
And when your crust helps that completely set custard with out cracking, shrinking, or burning? That’s not simply approach. That’s custom, bolstered. Carry it ahead, one pie shell at a time!
🥧 Reduce to the Crust Q&A
Shaunda’s straight solutions to widespread questions.
What’s the finest crust for candy potato pie?
A standard Southern shortcrust (my exact recipe under, or store-bought “pie crust pastry”) made with butter or a butter-shortening mix gives one of the best texture and stability for custard filling.
Do you bake candy potato pie crust earlier than including filling?
Not for this recipe. Baking the crust and filling collectively prevents over-browning and retains the custard balanced.
Why is your candy potato pie crust soggy?
Most frequently from underbaking, slicing too quickly, or not inserting it on the decrease oven rack when cooking. Additionally, let the pie cool totally earlier than reducing.
Can I exploit store-bought crust?
Sure. Simply make certain it’s unbaked.
Servings: 8
Energy: 168kcal
Cook dinner ModeStop your display screen from going darkish
cheese grater, or all-purpose scraper for the butter
fork, or electrical mixer with a dough hook
Rolling Pin
Freeze the butter for 10 minutes.
Subsequent, use the bigger holes of a cheese grater (or slice with an all-purpose scraper) to grate the butter into small, pea-sized bits. It will assist the dough come collectively with out overworking it.
Return the grated butter to the freezer for one more 10 minutes.
When you look ahead to the butter, mix the flour, sugar, and salt in a mixing bowl.
Add the chilly grated butter and shortening, mixing rapidly with a fork or utilizing an electrical mixer fitted with a dough hook till the combination could be very crumbly.
Drizzle chilly water, one tablespoon at a time, over the dough combination and toss or combine to moisten it. Proceed including the remaining water till the dough is crumbly and holds collectively. Proceed including water till the dough is crumbly however holds collectively. (It’s possible you’ll not want all of the water, or you’ll be able to add extra by the tablespoon if the dough feels too dry.)
Flip the combination out onto a clear work floor. Use your arms to press the dough collectively right into a tough mass. Gently fold one half of the dough over itself, repeating this 3 times till it types a ball.
Wrap the dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate it for no less than six hours, ideally in a single day. This resting interval permits the gluten to loosen up and the butter to relax, making certain the dough is cool and simple to work with when it goes into the oven. It will assist create a young, flaky crust.
Take away the dough from the fridge, and let it sit at room temperature for five to 10 minutes, or till it turns into barely pliable. Whereas it rests, grease the pie pan.
Then, place the dough on a floured floor, and gently roll it out with a rolling pin till it is about 1 inch bigger than your pie plate. Be certain the dough is rolled evenly, with no thick edges.
Fastidiously fold the dough in half, then place it in a greased pie plate and unfold it, urgent it gently into the pan whereas avoiding stretching it to suit.
Use kitchen scissors or a knife to trim the surplus dough, leaving a 1-inch overhang.
Fold the overhang beneath itself and crimp or flute the perimeters.
Energy: 168kcal | Carbohydrates: 20g | Protein: 3g | Fats: 9g | Saturated Fats: 2g | Polyunsaturated Fats: 2g | Monounsaturated Fats: 3g | Trans Fats: 1g | Ldl cholesterol: 1mg | Sodium: 229mg | Potassium: 38mg | Fiber: 1g | Sugar: 2g | Vitamin A: 15IU | Calcium: 15mg | Iron: 1mg
Created and examined by Shaunda Necole, creator of The Soul Meals Pot® (actual prepare dinner, actual kitchen). Rooted in African American culinary traditions, with trendy shortcuts that by no means sacrifice taste or legacy. No AI-generated directions. Each measurement, timing be aware, and approach is written, cooked, and verified by Shaunda, with make-it-your-way steering so you’ll be able to prepare dinner confidently with the instruments you’ve gotten.
Like this publish? Pin the under picture to your Pinterest “Soul Meals Recipes” board!
Uncover one of the best soul meals dinner concepts, together with conventional Sunday plates, straightforward weeknight meals, and genuine Black Southern dinner recipes with flavorful sides and menu inspiration constructed to feed each household and legacy.
Get the recipes!
